Skip to main content

The Story of Edgar Sawtelle: A Novel by David Wroblewski: book review





The Story of Edgar Sawtelle (2008) is set in mid-west America, west of Mellon, at Chequamegon National Forest in northern Wisconsin, in the 1940-50s. It is the story of Edgar Sawtelle, a 14-year-old mute boy, living on his parent’s farm, where they breed dogs. Edgar can hear, but he can’t speak.

It commences briefly in South Korea in 1952, which at first glance seems confusing, but 90% into the book this location becomes clear. The main story commences as an epic generational tale in 1919 with Edgar’s grandfather John, a dairy farmer, who established the dog breeding farm. John and his wife raised two boys: Gar and Claude. Gar stayed on the land, while Claude left.

Gar marries Trudy, and they have one son: Edgar. Trudy trains the dogs and teaches Edgar sign language. The family’s affinity with the dogs is extraordinary, but it also fires their desire to create a new breed. One noted breeder comments that this is ‘common vanity, one that every breeder has indulged during a weak moment.’ But the family persist with their goal.

Gar dies during a storm. His father’s death haunts Edgar: ‘If I could have made a sound.’ He knows the future of the farm depends on him, despite his immense grief. But then Claude returns to the family farm after 20 years away and begins infiltrating himself into the business and into Trudy’s life, to the distress and rising resentment of Edgar. Edgar, always ‘so inward and stoic’ becomes increasingly more uncommunicative.

The vet’s accident on the Sawtelle farm is the turning point in the novel. Edgar feels responsible for his fall and flees into the Chequamegon National Forest with three dogs. The vet’s son, Glen, meets Claude at his father’s funeral where Claude plants the seeds of revenge. Glen takes the bait and tries to find Edgar. The ending may not please some readers.


The novel has been touted as ‘the extraordinary debut novel that became a modern classic’ with a Shakespearean ending – following the plot in Hamlet exceptionally closely. The novel has a gripping psychological plot – the classic mother-son, uncle-defacto jealousy as well as the jealousy between the two brothers, Gar and Claude. It also has the insidious infiltration and deceptions of Claude the prodigal returnee, the parallel development of the mute dogs and mute son, and the remoteness of the wilderness, all making this an intriguing story. But there are also a host of confusions and loose threads that often makes this a frustrating read with more questions than answers. It seems to be one of those ‘love it or hate it’ novels that raises the ire of readers due to the ending – which diverges radically from the rest of the Hamletic plot.
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Pir-E-Kamil - The Perfect Mentor by Umera Ahmed: book review

The Perfect Mentor pbuh  (2011) is set in Lahore and Islamabad in Pakistan. The novel commences with Imama Mubeen in medical university. She wants to be an eye specialist. Her parents have arranged for her to marry her first cousin Asjad. Salar Sikander, her neighbour, is 18 years old with an IQ of 150+ and a photographic memory. He has long hair tied in a ponytail. He imbibes alcohol, treats women disrespectfully and is generally a “weird chap” and a rude, belligerent teenager. In the past three years he has tried to commit suicide three times. He tries again. Imama and her brother, Waseem, answer the servant’s call to help Salar. They stop the bleeding from his wrist and save his life. Imama and Asjad have been engaged for three years, because she wants to finish her studies first. Imama is really delaying her marriage to Asjad because she loves Jalal Ansar. She proposes to him and he says yes. But he knows his parents won’t agree, nor will Imama’s parents. ...
1 comment
Read more

Flaws in the Glass, a self-portrait by Patrick White: book review

The manuscript, Flaws in the Glass (1981), is Patrick Victor Martindale White’s autobiography. White, born in 1912 in England, migrated to Sydney, Australia, when he was six months old. For three years, at the age of 20, he studied French and German literature at King’s College at the University of Cambridge in England. Throughout his life, he published 12 novels. In 1957 he won the inaugural Miles Franklin Literary Award for Voss, published in 1956. In 1961, Riders in the Chariot became a best-seller, winning the Miles Franklin Literary Award. In 1973, he was the first Australian author to be awarded the Nobel Prize for Literature for The Eye of the Storm, despite many critics describing his works as ‘un-Australian’ and himself as ‘Australia’s most unreadable novelist.’ In 1979, The Twyborn Affair was short-listed for the Booker Prize, but he withdrew it from the competition to give younger writers the opportunity to win the award. His autobiography, Flaws in the Glass...
Post a Comment
Read more

Sister cities discussed: Canberra and Islamabad

Two months ago, in March 2015, Australia and Pakistan agreed to explore ways to deepen ties. The relationship between Australia and Pakistan has been strong for decades, and the two countries continue to keep dialogues open. The annual bilateral discussions were held in Australia in March to continue engagements on a wide range of matters of mutual interest. The Pakistan delegation discussed points of interest will include sports, agriculture, economic growth, trade, border protection, business, and education. The possible twinning of the cities of Canberra, the capital of Australia, and Islamabad, the capital of Pakistan, were also on the agenda (i.e. called twin towns or sister cities). Sister City relationships are twinning arrangements that build friendships as well as government, business, culture, and community linkages. Canberra currently has international Sister City relationships with Beijing in China and Nara in Japan. One example of existing...
1 comment
Read more